Gomez was dressed in a very Gossip Girl-like blue plaid mini skirt and sweater outfit; she was previously seen wearing a tan coat layered over the look. But outerwear can change the entire vibe of an outfit. For Gomez’s Coney Island scene, her winter parka, long black scarf, and gray beanie render the pairing decidedly more casual.

Here’s the outfit with the tan coat she was seen wearing before:

Gomez was photographed wearing the outfit again days later with the parka—sans beanie and scarf:

Gomez has worn an entire closet’s worth of greatcoats while filming the show’s second season over the last few months.

Only Murders in the Building costume designer Dana Covarrubiasspoke to ELLE.com during the show’s first season about Gomez’s character Mabel’s style—and why she wears so many bright-colored clothes.

“Her whole concept was basically that her costumes were a type of armor,” Covarrubias said. “So she’s using these really bright colors in the same way as an animal with a brightly colored coat: ‘Beware. Danger. Leave me alone. Back off.’”