The debut collection, which drops today, features a treasure trove of eye shadow palettes, eyeliner pencils, powder blushes, and color sticks. List’s personal favorite is the Love Child Pleyer Palette ($36), a
collection of gorgeous rosy and turquoise shades inspired by the dreamy energy of vintage California in the ’60s. “It’s super colorful,” she says. “I love wearing those pinks every day.” She also raves about the Pley Date All Over Color Sticks ($18), which come in beautiful shimmery colors such as Moon Dust and Sunshine State. List loves how foolproof they are and uses the sheer and blendable formulas on her eyes, cheeks, and nose and all over her body.
With Gen Z beauty reaching new levels of creativity, the Pley Things Stick On Adornments ($16–$24) will, no doubt, be a hit as well. The assortment of mix-and-match pearls, graphic shapes, and rhinestones are easy to use and add an eye-catching statement to any look. “I love lining the pearls underneath the eye when everything else is clean,” List tells us of her go-to look right now.